 |
| Register | Login | |||||
 |
Main
| Memberlist
| Active users
| ACS
| Commons
| Calendar
| Online users Ranks | FAQ | Color Chart | Photo album | IRC Chat |
|
| | ||
|
| Register | Login | |||||
|
Main
| Memberlist
| Active users
| ACS
| Commons
| Calendar
| Online users Ranks | FAQ | Color Chart | Photo album | IRC Chat |
|
| | ||
| 0 user currently in Lost Section. |
| Acmlm's Board - I2 Archive - Lost Section - Mario in the RPG Realm |
 |  |  |
| Pages: 1 2 3 | Add to favorites | "RSS" Feed | Next newer thread | Next older thread |
Which Mario RPG do you think is the best?| Mario has triple-jumped his way into the RPG genre over the past 8 years, but out of all three of the RPG's, which one do you think is the best? Why? | Super Mario RPG: Legend if the Seven Stars |
40.5%, 17 votes | Paper Mario |
26.2%, 11 votes | Mario and Luigi: Superstar Saga |
31.0%, 13 votes | Bah. All of them suck. |
2.4%, 1 vote | Multi-voting is disabled.
| |
| User | Post | ||
Aioria Boss Bass  Yes I will!! ;D  Middle Ages Warrior Level: 58 Posts: 28/1567 EXP: 1516086 For next: 61460 Since: 03-15-04 From: near the pneumon ultramicroscop icsilicovolcanoconiosis land Since last post: 19 days Last activity: 19 days |
| ||
| smRPG has the best strack, the best battles and the coolest bosses. why? because the great majority of denemies is totally new, and there are tons of new characters, smithy, booster, all of them great. and the boss battle song is teh best song of all the series  btw, i also love p mario and s saga, but in this series, lofthe7stars receives my vote  |
|||
jasukan Panser Level: 30 Posts: 53/344 EXP: 155950 For next: 9919 Since: 03-15-04 Since last post: 135 days Last activity: 62 days |
| ||
| I like Mario RPG. First RPG I ever played, which got me hooked to RPGs. That game holds a special place in my heart. And it's the only RPG game of Mario I've played. :/ | |||
Destiny Smasher Red Cheep-cheep Level: 24  Posts: 25/216 EXP: 77554 For next: 571 Since: 03-15-04 From: NOT HERE, thank the Star Spirits. Since last post: 368 days Last activity: 43 days |
| ||
| Yes, there's no denying it. Mario RPG is one of the games I value most. It's sheer awesomeness. It does, indeed, hold a special place in my heart. If it weren't for that game, who knows what would've become of me...Chrono Trigger/Cross...FFVII...Who knows if I would've been interested in them...? But the question is which one is the best as a game. And I still look at Paper Mario as the best of the three in general. It had everything it should've, it just lacked that Squaresoft touch, is all. But otherwise it was great. The original Mario RPG just...Is boring, now. After beating it 7 times and mastering it, it feels more like your average RPG. But the idea it brought- bringing action to turn based battles- was VERY awesome, and I'm glad that Paper Mario and SS have further evolved this practice. |
|||
ForteMaster Goomba Level: 9 Posts: 10/22 EXP: 2512 For next: 650 Since: 03-19-04 Since last post: 590 days Last activity: 339 days |
| ||
| M&L. It had the best of both worlds-Awesome Mario action, PROPER RPG-style level-up (Paper Mario lacked it), and an awesome story. And yeah, Luigi's a main character. | |||
|
Destiny Smasher Red Cheep-cheep Level: 24 Posts: 39/216 EXP: 77554 For next: 571 Since: 03-15-04 From: NOT HERE, thank the Star Spirits. Since last post: 368 days Last activity: 43 days |
| ||
| Paper Mario had a proper level-up system. It made perfect sense. Obviously, M&L has a more classic style. M&L IS an awesome game. But it's just to short...I dunno...It's missing what Paper Mario had. The flair, the classic Mario-ness...It's a great game, and it's wicked that Mario and Luigi work together, but... The only 'side-quest' type deals are, like...The mini-games. Besides, Paper Mario's Badge point system wins hands down for the equipment system, I've gotta admit. Perfect for strategy... I just wish Paper Mario had a harder difficulty level or something... You go through SuperStar Saga in this fashion: Pea Badges on both Bros. Work pants on both Bros. Through the WHOLE GAME. Bad guys are doing, like, half your HP to you by the end of the game. MWAHA! Now that's fun. My 99 Super Mushrooms, and 99 1-Up Supers might actually come into play! But after playing that game for about 60 hours (HOLY CRAP!! O_o Didn't realize it...) you won't need too many of them. |
|||
JaCory Porcupo Level: 29  Posts: 116/323 EXP: 141854 For next: 6031 Since: 03-15-04 Since last post: 69 days Last activity: 17 days |
| ||
| Paper Mario defintly, probly my favorite mario games of all time. Don't really like the other two though. | |||
|
Destiny Smasher Red Cheep-cheep Level: 24 Posts: 46/216 EXP: 77554 For next: 571 Since: 03-15-04 From: NOT HERE, thank the Star Spirits. Since last post: 368 days Last activity: 43 days |
| ||
| YES! This poll is doing exactly what I hoped it would do- tie three ways! Thus showing that all three of the Mario RPG's are great games for different qualities. I'm admit that Superstar Saga has a few fun minigames, though.  I got addicted to a couple last night, stocking up on Hee Beans.Hehe...I've got that game about down. I'm totally massacring it right now... |
|||
|
Kefka Indefinitely Unbanned Level: 81 Posts: 372/3392 EXP: 4826208 For next: 166641 Since: 03-15-04 From: Pomona, CALIFORNIA BABY! Since last post: 4 hours Last activity: 4 hours |
| ||
| I changed my mind... the humor in M&L is nice, but SMRPG's is better. I decided this as I replayed SMRPG for the first time in a long time right now. There is no funnier character in the SMRPG series than Booster, baby!!! The Snifits are great, too. Popple is the only guy I think that compares with Booster in any stretch of the imagination from M&L. | |||
|
Destiny Smasher Red Cheep-cheep Level: 24 Posts: 51/216 EXP: 77554 For next: 571 Since: 03-15-04 From: NOT HERE, thank the Star Spirits. Since last post: 368 days Last activity: 43 days |
| ||
| *chuckles* See? It's not so easy, is it? All three of them are great games! Heck, who knows? Maybe my opinion will change... I mean, I don't like Paper Mario more than the other two- I like all three for diferent aspects. But I think it's the best one as a GAME- right now, anyway. Interesting race we have going here... |
|||
|
MasterMario Newcomer Level: 6  Posts: 7/9 EXP: 657 For next: 250 Since: 03-20-04 From: Sumter, SC Since last post: 578 days Last activity: 339 days |
| ||
Legend of the 7 Stars was the best. Paper Mario was the worst! I think Square should make another game with Nintendo, like Super Mario Bros.: Smithy's Revenge. Paper Mario didn't had good gameplay. Great ideas, but it lack some stuff. ML S was just so-so.Scores: LOT7S: 9.5/10 PM: 2/10 ML S: 7:10 |
|||
|
Destiny Smasher Red Cheep-cheep Level: 24 Posts: 65/216 EXP: 77554 For next: 571 Since: 03-15-04 From: NOT HERE, thank the Star Spirits. Since last post: 368 days Last activity: 43 days |
| ||
| For someone who hates Paper Mario, you have a Paper Mario avatar! Good gameplay? Yes, Paper Mario had good gameplay. What DIDN'T it have that you think is 'good?' It had a lot of unique elements to it. Yes, Square SHOULD do anotehr Mario RPG. Smithy's Revenge? God, no, please come up with something new and original. Superstar Saga was very original if only for the fact that we got to see a NEW KINGDOM!!! HOKY CRAP!! |
|||
|
MasterMario Newcomer Level: 6 Posts: 9/9 EXP: 657 For next: 250 Since: 03-20-04 From: Sumter, SC Since last post: 578 days Last activity: 339 days |
| ||
Originally posted by Destiny Smasher (sigh) Okay. I admit! The only wrong things are this: You can only have one party member in battle at a time, I wanted stronger bad guys(Highest HP: 99), and your party members have no HP! (They just stop for a few turns) Okay, I'll change PM to a 8/10. Plus, Smithy's Revenge isn't a good idea to me, either. I just wish Mallow, Geno, or the Paper Mario party members will be playable in another game! |
|||
|
Destiny Smasher Red Cheep-cheep Level: 24 Posts: 119/216 EXP: 77554 For next: 571 Since: 03-15-04 From: NOT HERE, thank the Star Spirits. Since last post: 368 days Last activity: 43 days |
| ||
| The Paper Mario sequel is shaping up to be quite nice. I don't know if you'll have more than one partner at a time (that's part of the strategy, of course.) but I have evidence to support your party members are REALLY members with their own HP. I saw a screen shot, go take a peek! I'm really excited about how the sequel is shaping up. And yes, it would've been nice if there was a Hard Mode. Maybe the sequel will have one. |
|||
|
Toadeeboy Banned for being a flaming jackass, thinking he could get away with it by stating he's only doing it in his last post. Level: 27  Posts: 73/264 EXP: 104840 For next: 11319 Since: 03-15-04 From: Inside Paper Mario Since last post: 502 days Last activity: 339 days |
| ||
| I would say Paper Mario, because it had the best gameplay, and many cool features. Here's my ratings. SMRPG: 7.9/10 PM: 9.9/10 M&LSS: 9.7/10 PM2: 10/10! |
|||
|
Iggy Koopa Red Cheep-cheep Level: 24 Posts: 62/214 EXP: 76441 For next: 1684 Since: 03-16-04 Since last post: 66 days Last activity: 12 days |
| ||
Originally posted by wolfman2000 I can. I have a TV in my car. Anyway, back on topic. Super Mario RPG was too short in my opinon. If I tried, I'm sure I can beat it in two days. Paper Mario was good, but it was a very unorthodox RPG. The way the party worked, the level up system, I didn't like any of that. I liked the badge system though. Mario and Luigi Superstar Saga was sort of unorthodox as well. The music was good, I suppose, but it lacked replay value. |
|||
|
Ice Goomba Level: 9  Posts: 16/24 EXP: 2829 For next: 333 Since: 04-02-04 From: Columbus, OH Since last post: 567 days Last activity: 339 days |
| ||
| Super Mario RPG rocks! Sure, I have beaten it a lot, but it is still very good. A lot of my friends like it too. | |||
|
Morton Koopa Jr Goomba Level: 9  Posts: 5/22 EXP: 2485 For next: 677 Since: 04-01-04 Since last post: 397 days Last activity: 162 days |
| ||
| *smacks the idiot that voted for "All of them sucked"* Anyway, I'm going to have to go with Paper Mario. I liked it's battle system the best, and it seemed to have the most fun stuff do on it (fun stuff being stuff like doing favors for Koopa Koot, etc.) (edited by Morton Koopa Jr on 04-06-04 04:40 AM) |
|||
|
seagram Go away Spammy, warned about it Stupid, warned about it Banned (permanently) for it Level: 19  Posts: 53/116 EXP: 30131 For next: 5646 Since: 03-30-04 Since last post: 564 days Last activity: 339 days |
| ||
| I vote for smrpg because the game plays music from ff series when you fight culex. | |||
Slash Dafter Kodondo Level: 38  Posts: 34/584 EXP: 338934 For next: 31513 Since: 04-04-04 From: E. Millinocket, ME Since last post: 9 hours Last activity: 9 hours |
| ||
| I'd say Mario RPG, because I've gotten the furthest in that than in the other 2. I like the music and the strange bosses. | |||
Zerodius Aquamentus Level: 65  Posts: 198/2036 EXP: 2243783 For next: 91845 Since: 03-16-04 From: ??? Since last post: 2 days Last activity: 2 days |
| ||
| Myself... It's Paper Mario all the way. I won't post a huge review that compare all three but anyway... In a nutshell, Mario RPG is a challenge-free eye candy, Paper Mario is a surprisingly deep and challenging game, Superstar is a mix of the two (it mix Paper Mario's qualities and Mario RPG's flaws to be more exact). Of course, all of this is only my humble opinion... |
| Pages: 1 2 3 | Add to favorites | "RSS" Feed | Next newer thread | Next older thread |
| Acmlm's Board - I2 Archive - Lost Section - Mario in the RPG Realm |
| | |
