Points of Required Attention™
Please chime in on a proposed restructuring of the ROM hacking sections.
Views: 88,542,663
Main | FAQ | Uploader | IRC chat | Radio | Memberlist | Active users | Latest posts | Calendar | Stats | Online users | Search 05-05-24 10:46 PM
Guest: Register | Login

0 users currently in General Chat | 1 guest | 2 bots

Main - General Chat - SMB2 Proto Released New thread | New reply

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6

The Kins
Posted on 05-14-07 01:09 PM Link | Quote | ID: 35219


Paratroopa
Level: 28

Posts: 64/140
EXP: 131329
Next: 9

Since: 02-19-07
From: AUSSIELAND

Last post: 5922 days
Last view: 5922 days
Posted by Xkeeper
Posted by The Kins
Or am I retarded and this would break horrifically?
It'd probably break a lot of things, as all sprite code is run twice and a lot of in-game timers are cut short (the rugs, for example, don't last quite as long as usual).

Some other bad things are present too, like the game lagging really badly at 2-4 objects.
Ah, fair enough. Was just wondering because I find the double-executed sprites oddly hilarious.

iamstillhiro1112
Posted on 05-14-07 09:49 PM (rev. 2 of 05-14-07 09:56 PM) Link | Quote | ID: 35294


Paragoomba
Level: 21

Posts: 40/66
EXP: 42446
Next: 7497

Since: 03-09-07

Last post: 6128 days
Last view: 6120 days
I'm pretty sure this little stunt has sealed the fate for those hoping the Sonic X-treme beta will ever be released to the public from one of the private collectors who bought it.

Posted by Tweaker
So what, do you want me to say I'm sorry or something? There's always two sides to the fence, and you should know that.

Besides that, it should be obvious that the fault isn't just on me for leaking this. If this dump was supposed to be as private as you thought it was, how did I obtain it? Why is there an IRC channel with 30+ people who have said ROM? If you want to be super-anal about how you deal with collectors and whatnot (which is a viewpoint I can certainly understand), then you need to work harder to keep private ROM dumps, uh... private. Because you "think" you may be able to trust all your friends that you hand them to (or whatever), but remember that a majority of people won't hesitate to turn on others at any time. I kept this ROM private for a few months (ie, I've had it for a while), but what good does that do? Waiting for a collector to give a thumbs up that would probably never happen? And, even if it does, what circumstances would have changed? Either way, the ROM would've been out there, and I doubt he was keeping it just to sell it later or something.

Whatever, I'm rambling now... But I don't regret one bit of what I did. I'm not going to claim responsibility for how a group of people act; neither the "sonic fags" or the "collector fags." But I got ahold of an unreleased game, so I did what I thought would be best for the thriving of both this community, and a fair share of others I frequent. If that negatively affected any other communities, I'm not about to bow down and take it in the ass over it. I mean, I'm sorry that turned out bad for you, but that's just the way things happened.

What I'd do is, if you find another proto like this, and manage to convince the withholder of the cart to dump it, then, uh... DON'T TELL ANYBODY. It'll save the trouble you'll get from people knowing of its presence, and the chance of it leaking to the wrong person again, essentially repeating this situation.


Thats the arrogant tweaker I remember for the Simon wai forums. Sorry about your de-administrating.

The Kins
Posted on 05-15-07 03:32 AM Link | Quote | ID: 35425


Paratroopa
Level: 28

Posts: 65/140
EXP: 131329
Next: 9

Since: 02-19-07
From: AUSSIELAND

Last post: 5922 days
Last view: 5922 days
Posted by iamstillhiro1112
I'm pretty sure this little stunt has sealed the fate for those hoping the Sonic X-treme beta will ever be released to the public from one of the private collectors who bought it.
Your mistake is thinking they'd ever release it in the first place.

Sharing's caring, and they ain't sharing, so...

BMF54123
Posted on 05-15-07 04:23 AM Link | Quote | ID: 35442


Buzzy Beetle
Level: 44

Posts: 206/375
EXP: 575736
Next: 35549

Since: 02-19-07
From: [citation needed]

Last post: 6096 days
Last view: 6096 days
This is all I know:

The ROM was not supposed to have been given to "30+ people" in an IRC chat room. This ROM was supposed to have stayed between the owner, the original obtainer of the ROM, and a few trusted associates behind CLOSED DOORS strictly for research purposes, since the owner wanted the differences fully documented, inside and out. The best theory right now is that one of these "trusted associates" decided to pass it off to a friend, who was not a part of this group and thus not bound by its rules, and it spread from there.

Of course, this is pretty much how the majority of unintentional leaks happen, and the rules behind said "closed doors" have since been changed to prevent this from happening again.

____________________
[citation needed]

Kernal
Posted on 05-15-07 04:37 AM Link | Quote | ID: 35444

Gone
Level: 88

Posts: 1617/1881
EXP: 6467078
Next: 183586

Since: 02-20-07

Last post: 6156 days
Last view: 6146 days
Why are people so greedy about this kind of stuff and hog the protos to themselves, anyway?

TheGreatGuy
Posted on 05-15-07 04:46 AM Link | Quote | ID: 35449


Beezo
Level: 49

Posts: 203/480
EXP: 832113
Next: 51770

Since: 03-15-07

Last post: 5777 days
Last view: 5642 days
I must agree with Kernal. I'm sorry, but why exactly would someone want to keep it to themselves? The only reason I can see is to be an ass and be all "Look at me, I have this awesome proto, bow down to me! But you can't have it, cause I'm better than you." I just don't understand why people would keep it completely private and not release it in any way, other than taunting screens. What do they have to lose? I don't see a reason to keep stuff like this so hidden, it seems to me it's better for all involved if they would just release it.

____________________
There are things I want to put here. Like a cool picture, my 8-bit theatre character test result, my MS and RO characters... But it's 12 AM, and I'm sleepy.

Krisan Thyme
Posted on 05-15-07 05:04 AM Link | Quote | ID: 35452


Red Cheep-cheep
Level: 34

Posts: 171/216
EXP: 251636
Next: 2015

Since: 02-21-07

Last post: 6130 days
Last view: 6107 days
I'd have to third that as well, I suppose.. I can understand a collector wanting to keep the original copy for themselves, as it has a physical shape (as opposed to a digital one) and some form of attachment or satisfaction can be gained from knowing you own something as rare as that.. But the ROM? Meh, you're just stepping beyond the boundaries of a collector and into greedy territory.

Mind you though, I see where BMF is coming from on this subject too.. And he's right. It is much more realistic to uphold those kinds of rules than to expect one of these collectors to be sensible enough to freely distribute something like the ROM. That said, it would have probably been better if this hadn't gotten leaked as it did..

Posted by setz
Posted by Bloodstar
Am I the only one not overly excited about this?

I dunno, maybe it's just me, but I've never cared for prototypes much.


I'm not overly excited since its just a prototype of a "special" translation; had it been a proto of DDP however...

Agreed. A DDP Beta might have been interesting.. This however is not really all that big a deal.

The Kins
Posted on 05-15-07 07:38 AM Link | Quote | ID: 35503


Paratroopa
Level: 28

Posts: 67/140
EXP: 131329
Next: 9

Since: 02-19-07
From: AUSSIELAND

Last post: 5922 days
Last view: 5922 days
Posted by TheGreatGuy
What do they have to lose?
The depressing amounts of money they can sell the slowly-bitrotting cartridge/CD/harddisk/litterbox for, and the world's tiniest power trip.

Metal_Man88
Posted on 05-15-07 09:37 AM Link | Quote | ID: 35526


Level: 48

Posts: 206/458
EXP: 777085
Next: 46458

Since: 02-19-07
From: The Void

Last post: 3040 days
Last view: 3039 days
Pffft. Let them have their games.

If everybody just treated them like the code they were and just went "Fine, keep your old game, I won't buy it for more than the original price of the finished game" they'd be screwed. In fact, they'd probably give up all together, unless they wanted to collect them, in which case, good for them--it'll bitrot, their copy of the ROM will go away when they die, and their example can be held up to the other people obsessed with such things as a reason for not being so childish.

It's a 2-way street. Sometimes I think people should stop giving these people money and let them rot. In some cases, literally.

iamstillhiro1112
Posted on 05-15-07 10:53 AM Link | Quote | ID: 35528


Paragoomba
Level: 21

Posts: 41/66
EXP: 42446
Next: 7497

Since: 03-09-07

Last post: 6128 days
Last view: 6120 days
Meh, who knows. The owner of the Sonic X-treme beta could of one day had a generous streak and at least offered info on the game. Like the guy who showed off info for the SMB2 beta. But things like this don't make those chances any greater. I say this beta wasn't worth burning a bridge, all the differences were fully documented. I ain't seeing much while playing this rom that I didn't find documented at the mushroom kingdom.

As for tweakers comment about doing this "for the good of the people". Thats really bs. This was done to give an exclusive to the Sonic cult site. It even says so in the message board thread this rom release originated from. It's basically Zelda 3 beta all over again, except this time with a real rom.

The Kins
Posted on 05-15-07 11:00 AM (rev. 2 of 05-15-07 11:00 AM) Link | Quote | ID: 35530


Paratroopa
Level: 28

Posts: 68/140
EXP: 131329
Next: 9

Since: 02-19-07
From: AUSSIELAND

Last post: 5922 days
Last view: 5922 days
Posted by Krisan Thyme
Agreed. A DDP Beta might have been interesting.. This however is not really all that big a deal.
Nintendo prototypes are as rare as hen's penises - most of the prototypes nowadays generally have Nintendo reps handcuffed to them. That's why this is worth noticing.

Posted by iamstillhiro1112
Meh, who knows. The owner of the Sonic X-treme beta could of one day had a generous streak and at least offered info on the game.
Isn't the game's frickin' programmer part of the Sonic community? I'm fairly certain he's answered a bunch of questions and released a lot of media and sprites from the game's various development stages. There's really no more info to be gleaned from Sonic Xtreme without having the actual tech demo itself, and pretending otherwise is daydreaming.

Ailure
Posted on 05-15-07 11:22 AM Link | Quote | ID: 35533

Hats
Steam Board2 group
Level: 121

Posts: 795/3965
EXP: 19794068
Next: 262628

Since: 02-19-07
From: Sweden, Skåne

Last post: 3311 days
Last view: 2061 days
Well, I do suspect it's leaked from Bergsala due to it appearing in Sweden somehow.

I doubt Bergsala would have as high security with beta carts as, let say Nintendo of America. Although they probably got the cart from USA, to judge if it would be import-worthy. If the original story about the guy living in Sweden found it in Sweden is true. Unless I'm confusing with some other prototype.

Someone might gotten his hands over it, Bergsala might just either forgotten about the beta or thought it wasn't a big deal and the old owner sold it to some store, probably thinking it wasn't a big deal.

____________________
AIM: gamefreak1337, MSN: Emil_sim@spray.se, XMPP: ailure@xmpp.kafuka.org


Tweaker
Posted on 05-15-07 07:21 PM Link | Quote | ID: 35570


Red Koopa
Level: 28

Posts: 93/139
EXP: 129926
Next: 1412

Since: 02-19-07
From: Rochester, NY

Last post: 5804 days
Last view: 5711 days
Posted by iamstillhiro1112
I'm pretty sure this little stunt has sealed the fate for those hoping the Sonic X-treme beta will ever be released to the public from one of the private collectors who bought it.

Posted by Tweaker
So what, do you want me to say I'm sorry or something? There's always two sides to the fence, and you should know that.

Besides that, it should be obvious that the fault isn't just on me for leaking this. If this dump was supposed to be as private as you thought it was, how did I obtain it? Why is there an IRC channel with 30+ people who have said ROM? If you want to be super-anal about how you deal with collectors and whatnot (which is a viewpoint I can certainly understand), then you need to work harder to keep private ROM dumps, uh... private. Because you "think" you may be able to trust all your friends that you hand them to (or whatever), but remember that a majority of people won't hesitate to turn on others at any time. I kept this ROM private for a few months (ie, I've had it for a while), but what good does that do? Waiting for a collector to give a thumbs up that would probably never happen? And, even if it does, what circumstances would have changed? Either way, the ROM would've been out there, and I doubt he was keeping it just to sell it later or something.

Whatever, I'm rambling now... But I don't regret one bit of what I did. I'm not going to claim responsibility for how a group of people act; neither the "sonic fags" or the "collector fags." But I got ahold of an unreleased game, so I did what I thought would be best for the thriving of both this community, and a fair share of others I frequent. If that negatively affected any other communities, I'm not about to bow down and take it in the ass over it. I mean, I'm sorry that turned out bad for you, but that's just the way things happened.

What I'd do is, if you find another proto like this, and manage to convince the withholder of the cart to dump it, then, uh... DON'T TELL ANYBODY. It'll save the trouble you'll get from people knowing of its presence, and the chance of it leaking to the wrong person again, essentially repeating this situation.


Thats the arrogant tweaker I remember for the Simon wai forums. Sorry about your de-administrating.

Hahaha you're such a fucking idiot. I saw the shit you spewed on Lost Levels, I should've banned you like you said I did.

And my resignation was a choice, thanks. In fact, who ARE you? I don't even fucking know you and you're running your mouth like we go way back or something. Go sit in a corner and shit yourself you useless little prick.

And you're an even bigger idiot if you EVER thought X-Treme would be released.

____________________
Messenger info:
AIM: SonicTweaker
MSN: nibesto@gmail.com
GTalk: nibesto@gmail.com
Cool IRC Channels:
#retro | #cult | #acmlm

Cool Sites:
Sonic Retro | S2Beta | CulT | SGMC | Something Awful | HPZ | Hacking CulT | Acmlm's Board II

Thexare Blademoon
Posted on 05-15-07 07:33 PM Link | Quote | ID: 35571


Cheep-cheep
Level: 32

Posts: 102/180
EXP: 191453
Next: 14989

Since: 02-19-07

Last post: 5974 days
Last view: 5966 days
Ignore him, Tweaker. He's the guy that forgot either that Germans speak German or that Germany is a part of Europe.

iamstillhiro1112
Posted on 05-15-07 08:41 PM (rev. 2 of 05-15-07 08:46 PM) Link | Quote | ID: 35576


Paragoomba
Level: 21

Posts: 42/66
EXP: 42446
Next: 7497

Since: 03-09-07

Last post: 6128 days
Last view: 6120 days
I wasn't saying I wanted more Sonic X-treme info anyway. But the game has gained a mythical status among the Sonic fans. All indications at the time were that the game was gonna suck hard, yet since it went unreleased many people swear to the fact that the game was gonna rock.

As for not knowing about Germans, you're gonna have to refresh my memory on that one. I have no clue what you are talking about, you probably got me confused with someone else.

Posted by Tweaker
But I don't regret one bit of what I did.


You guys don't really need to speculate over who leaked the rom. Tweaker claims responsibility right there.

Posted by Tweaker
In fact, who ARE you? I don't even fucking know you and you're running your mouth like we go way back or something. Go sit in a corner and shit yourself you useless little prick.

And you're an even bigger idiot if you EVER thought X-Treme would be released.


Our history was breif, but your angerspeak has a way of being impactful. That is the effect you're going for right? So don't be suprised if someone remembers you.

Edit: And I didn't say you did the banning.

http://forums.lostlevels.org/viewtopic.php?p=18079#18079

But from your first post in Simon wais forum you would think that. "I fucking love pending approval." For those that don't know, pending approval is a form of banning there.

http://www.s2beta.com/forums/index.php?showtopic=8699&st=195


Thexare Blademoon
Posted on 05-15-07 09:19 PM Link | Quote | ID: 35586


Cheep-cheep
Level: 32

Posts: 103/180
EXP: 191453
Next: 14989

Since: 02-19-07

Last post: 5974 days
Last view: 5966 days
Posted by iamstillhiro1112

As for not knowing about Germans, you're gonna have to refresh my memory on that one. I have no clue what you are talking about, you probably got me confused with someone else.

Oh, it's quite simple, really, and I know I have the right guy here. Dragonsbretheren's FFIVAdvance (Europe) thread on the old board.

I was even nice enough to get you a link. Your account seems to have gotten deleted, but scroll down to my post and you'll see the account name that was used.

iamstillhiro1112
Posted on 05-15-07 10:23 PM (rev. 2 of 05-15-07 10:25 PM) Link | Quote | ID: 35608


Paragoomba
Level: 21

Posts: 44/66
EXP: 42446
Next: 7497

Since: 03-09-07

Last post: 6128 days
Last view: 6120 days
Ok, well, it was meant as a joke. Can't say humor is my strong point. Attribute that to watching too much Mystery Science theatre 3000.

Tweaker
Posted on 05-15-07 10:37 PM Link | Quote | ID: 35618


Red Koopa
Level: 28

Posts: 94/139
EXP: 129926
Next: 1412

Since: 02-19-07
From: Rochester, NY

Last post: 5804 days
Last view: 5711 days
Posted by iamstillhiro1112
Ok, well, it was meant as a joke. Can't say humor is my strong point. Attribute that to watching too much Mystery Science theatre 3000.

I attribute it to you being a faggot.

And pending approval isn't banning, dumbass, it's meant to restrict posting after the trial period. If you manage to get caught in there, you're probably an idiot.

____________________
Messenger info:
AIM: SonicTweaker
MSN: nibesto@gmail.com
GTalk: nibesto@gmail.com
Cool IRC Channels:
#retro | #cult | #acmlm

Cool Sites:
Sonic Retro | S2Beta | CulT | SGMC | Something Awful | HPZ | Hacking CulT | Acmlm's Board II

iamstillhiro1112
Posted on 05-15-07 11:06 PM Link | Quote | ID: 35644


Paragoomba
Level: 21

Posts: 45/66
EXP: 42446
Next: 7497

Since: 03-09-07

Last post: 6128 days
Last view: 6120 days
Not this time around. I had passed the test, and was a regular member, and that membership was reverted, right around the time you made the post about pending approvals.

And not knowing "What is the name of the level specific programming routines that are triggered only when certain conditions are fufilled in-game?" (one of the questions asked to get past pending approval) isn't something everyone knows. If you asked the average person on the street they wouldn't immediately know the answer. Or even "How long is each object's status table in Sonic 2?". I'm not the only one who found these tests ridiculous as you remember.

http://www.romhacking.net/forum/index.php/topic,3267.0.html

Tweaker
Posted on 05-16-07 12:37 AM Link | Quote | ID: 35659


Red Koopa
Level: 28

Posts: 95/139
EXP: 129926
Next: 1412

Since: 02-19-07
From: Rochester, NY

Last post: 5804 days
Last view: 5711 days
Posted by iamstillhiro1112
Not this time around. I had passed the test, and was a regular member, and that membership was reverted, right around the time you made the post about pending approvals.

Hi there buddy, learn to read! You're in pending retest, not pending approval. Everybody was put through that, and you're no exception. If you want back in, pass the test. Simple as that.


And not knowing "What is the name of the level specific programming routines that are triggered only when certain conditions are fufilled in-game?" (one of the questions asked to get past pending approval) isn't something everyone knows. If you asked the average person on the street they wouldn't immediately know the answer. Or even "How long is each object's status table in Sonic 2?". I'm not the only one who found these tests ridiculous as you remember.

http://www.romhacking.net/forum/index.php/topic,3267.0.html

Uh... no shit? The point is to research the answers to prove that you have the ability to do so, S2B isn't for your random internet idiot. For example, the answers to both those questions can be answered with a simple forum search, or even a google search. Don't whine to me if you can't handle that, since you know where the door is.

I also won't be responsible for arrogance on taking the test. Knowing their skill, however, I HAVE offered them board invites to pass the test. Whether or not they choose to accept them is up to them.

Do you think that just because other people share your opinion, it makes you right, or something? And opinion is not fact, dear, and you're doing little more than making yourself look like a bigger idiot than I initially anticipated you to be. Seriously, stop trying to blame everything on one person and look at the bigger picture here.

____________________
Messenger info:
AIM: SonicTweaker
MSN: nibesto@gmail.com
GTalk: nibesto@gmail.com
Cool IRC Channels:
#retro | #cult | #acmlm

Cool Sites:
Sonic Retro | S2Beta | CulT | SGMC | Something Awful | HPZ | Hacking CulT | Acmlm's Board II
Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6


Main - General Chat - SMB2 Proto Released New thread | New reply

Acmlmboard 2.1+4δ (2023-01-15)
© 2005-2023 Acmlm, blackhole89, Xkeeper et al.

Page rendered in 0.032 seconds. (322KB of memory used)
MySQL - queries: 117, rows: 146/146, time: 0.020 seconds.