| User | Post |
Link2004
Posts: 32/254 |
Mario and Luigi have the old school colors from SMB 1. Nice *. I don't know about the blue Luigi (fire flower)???. Overall, cool. |
SplinterCell
Posts: 12/12 |
The blue purple fire luigi pallete comes from an old calender I had of 8-bit nintendo games like metriod and mario2
the bar is on all levels exept for 2 which you find an entrance to another level
anywhere else is a sprite problem(just found out)which your might gonna have to die and see if it dose it again(but this is only in the level that level2 takes you to)
the "heads" are there to give you a hard time but I did't wan't them to be footballs
also i could care less about opinions about why i didn't just post a new thread, i just posted that ealier because the posts didn't match up to the new pics but in the future i'll just make a new thread |
GCNMario
Posts: 22/50 |
It's too damn short.
I know it is just a demo. But at least put the BAR at the end of every level. Maybe not a bar, but at least something, like a key hole, or a crystal object to end the level.
 |
KATW
Posts: 1772/3959 |
I have to say the screenies look very nice 
The Palettes on Mario and Luigi and rich... which I always have liked..
My only gripe is Luigi and the Fire Flower...
The Fire flower is too smiley.. and purple doesnt look good period. 
Other than that, its a good hack... maybe a bit too easy, but still good. |
Keikonium
Posts: 548/-2459 |
I personally like all the new ground textures. Especially the stone. But I have a few things to comment on:
Pic...
1. Why is it Super Gooder World Super Mario World? You should make the title something...else Just doesn't sound right. Also the Super Gooder World part has some funky letters. There white and odd, change there palettes. And change the date. Its 2004, 2005 now, not 1990, 1991 .
2. Everythings good, except is the mushroom sad? Also this looks like a place from the original game...
3. What Luigi San said about the ledge.
4. I have no idea whats going on here. I pray its either a new sprite or a bad glitch.... Also, why so much time?
5. Ground palette has some white lines, and the flower has a black nose...Mario's palette...
6. Just the flower, everything else is cool.
7. Same as above, LOVE the new turn blocks. They look 3d to me. One thing, why does LUIGI have a WARIO palette?
8. Lookin good, except for luigi's palette. Did you darken all the other palettes here? Looks nice.
9. Looks good
10. Looks cool, but mario looks odd...red clothes?
Just a few things I think should be fixed...I really like the looks of the edited graphics so I will try this hack out
8. |
Luigi-San
Posts: 57/736 |
On the left side, the edge is broken because of a ledge
|
Alastor the Stylish
Posts: 2046/7620 |
Well if you wanted to dispel any doubts, shouldn't you release another demo, or do you want us to sit here, thinking about how bad it is? |
SplinterCell
Posts: 11/12 |
The posts by other poeple were based on the earlier demo |
Aioria
Posts: 804/1567 |
the ground on screen 1 is quite good. imo if it was darker it would look better. make a darker green for it. |
Juggling Joker
Posts: 271/1033 |
Grain in screenshots is not something you should be concerning yourself with. Concern yourself with making your hack more enjoyable. |
SplinterCell
Posts: 9/12 |
well the ground sucks but I think the stone looks ok cause I wanted it to have a gainy rock feel but point out the one that has the most grain |
Cruel Justice
Posts: 273/1384 |
I'd hate to be the Simon Cowell of SMW hack critique, but the grainy stuff.
I understand it's your first hack but let's learn something from this shall we?
The grain made me think there was something wrong with the pictures, like you converted them to .jpg format. Once you learn how to make your own GFX, I think you'll actually be headed in a better direction. Otherwise, it's just an everyday hack. |
Alastor the Stylish
Posts: 1968/7620 |
Originally posted by SplinterCell
This seems vaguely similiar to something I've seen before, but I can't quite place my finger on what...
EDIT: Well. I don't use the phrase "hideously easy" often, but this is hideously easy. I only died once, in An Island 3. Sure, in the main game the difficulty may go up, but if it ever does, I'll just go back to An Island 2 and get the 53 1-ups from running along with the shell at the very beginning and jumping strategically. Additionally, you take stuff right out of the original and don't edit much. I'm aware this is just a demo, but you could at least try. |
Mario Maniac
Posts: 41/281 |
I don't thing it is so bad. My hack is not a great one too, but some of your levels remembered me the originals. |
Katastrophe
Posts: 47/187 |
The Vanilla Ice Castle is very good. But I agree with Aioria. The pallete from screen 9 is very strange. To your first hack, the hack is awesome! |
Aioria
Posts: 794/1567 |
it looks very good being this your first hack
I didnt like the paletes on screen 9, though, those red paletes are weird 
2 iggys? how the....!!!!??? |
SplinterCell
Posts: 7/12 |
My first hack.
Demo
http://www.freewebs.com/jaschult/new%20Super%20Gooder%20World%20DEMO.zip |
labmaster
