Acmlm's Board - I2 Archive - General Gaming - Best Game Competition Finale
| User | Post |
Ronin
Posts: 6/267 |
Originally posted by DahrkDaiz
Where were you people when it was time to vote? So much dislike for SMB3, yet more people voted for SMB3 than SSBM. If ya don't vote, there is no justice!
But of course I'm glad to see that SMB3 won. I love SSBM to death and all, but my heart will always belong to SMB3. For it being the only game I owned on the NES for a whole year, it provided me with enough things to do to last me a life time (and still does!)
Really, all I can say here is quoted for truth.
SSBM was really fun and stuff, I played it for a long time, but first of all, SMB3 was just classic fun. I can pick it up and jump on a bunch of guys, and I'll enjoy it.
But mostly, SSBM was too much like SSB, only they added a bunch more characters and several more moves, which made it more fun.
DDR failing close to the beginning was just sad though  |
DahrkDaiz
Posts: 796/885 |
Where were you people when it was time to vote? So much dislike for SMB3, yet more people voted for SMB3 than SSBM. If ya don't vote, there is no justice!
But of course I'm glad to see that SMB3 won. I love SSBM to death and all, but my heart will always belong to SMB3. For it being the only game I owned on the NES for a whole year, it provided me with enough things to do to last me a life time (and still does!) |
Xeolord
Posts: 3066/3418 |
Well, why don't you guys go play the Super Mario Bros 3. Challenge hack.  |
fabio
Posts: 646/1479 |
Originally posted by Trapster
Originally posted by Kyouji Craw
I wholeheartedly disagree with this  Super Mario 3 had world 7, which was pretty much made entirely out of a combination of evil and bad level design.
I enjoyed that World pretty much. I like those level designs and I didn
Alastor the Stylish
Posts: 7076/7620 |
Originally posted by Xeolord
Kyouji: I don't understand your Pipe Land arguement, did people "truly" say that made the game? 
Honestly that was my least favorite world, but SMB3 was still hands down an incredible game.
Argh, the whole thing is just not particularly good though, it's just that Pipe Land is the worst. Yeah, I used to really like SMB3, but then I went back and played it again recently and god dammit that game sucks. The game is not without its moments, obviously, but it is quite flawed, suffering a great deal from uneven level design and short levels. Combined with the fact that the first thing that comes to my mind when I think of that game is the autoscroll water level in world 7 just makes me hate it with every ounce of my soul. |
Ran-chan
Posts: 10945/12781 |
Originally posted by Kyouji Craw
I wholeheartedly disagree with this Super Mario 3 had world 7, which was pretty much made entirely out of a combination of evil and bad level design.
I enjoyed that World pretty much. I like those level designs and I didn |
Xeolord
Posts: 3048/3418 |
SSBM was great, but it hasn't been something I've gone back to and played over within the last couple of months or whatever, in which I could easily sit down to play SMB3 anytime.
Kyouji: I don't understand your Pipe Land arguement, did people "truly" say that made the game?
Honestly that was my least favorite world, but SMB3 was still hands down an incredible game. |
alte Hexe
Posts: 5006/5458 |
Not really. SMB 3 is BETTER because it is MORE innovative. It holds memories for me, fond memories. Playing it today I can still sit down and think "wow, those levels are short and many of them are easy. But wow, those are all gems!"
I can sit down and play SSBM and go "wow, this is retarded" and proceed to kick the fuck out of it for hours. Entertaining myself to no end, because I'm duking up an inanimate object that is not fun when added to another inanimate object that lets it work. |
Alastor the Stylish
Posts: 7069/7620 |
What's your point? This was not a most innovative game competition, this was a BEST game competition, and frankly Melee is a much better game than SMB3, even if it isn't as innovative. |
alte Hexe
Posts: 5000/5458 |
Let's compare this.
SMB3, completely innovative for its time.
SSBM, not innovative. It is just Power Stone or Super Smash Bros. Nothing more. There is nothing special about that game. |
Dracoon
Posts: 3426/3727 |
Originally posted by fabio
Why, why did SSBM lose to this? SMB3 is a good game but it's usually highly overated.
quoted for emphasis or w/e.
SMB3 wasn't really all that great, I thought Super Mario World was like 50x better  |
fabio
Posts: 515/1479 |
Why, why did SSBM lose to this? SMB3 is a good game but it's usually highly overated. |
Eval
Posts: 83/93 |
Im so sorry, but SSMB is way better than SMB3.  Anyway, I dont care that SMB3 won, they are both good games.  |
Alastor the Stylish
Posts: 7037/7620 |
I wholeheartedly disagree with this Super Mario 3 had world 7, which was pretty much made entirely out of a combination of evil and bad level design. Smash Bros Melee had pure awesome. Crappy level design... Pure awesome... Crappy level design... Pure awesome... YEAH BECAUSE CRAPPY LEVEL DESIGN IS OBVIOUSLY BETTER am I right? |
Xeolord
Posts: 2842/3418 |
w00tlasagna I guess.
I would have rather seen Super Metroid or Link to the Past make it to number one, but I won't complain with SMB3.
Here's to Super Mario Bros 3!
 |
alte Hexe
Posts: 4856/5458 |
I just BSd you with a ZERGLING rush n00bz. |
Legion
Posts: 4831/5657 |
WHO DIDN'T UNSTICKY THE THREAD BEFORE THEY PUT IT IN THE DISPLAY CASE?!
GG NOOBS LEG FOR TEH WIN |
NSNick
Posts: 3090/3875 |
Thanks. Coulda just PMed me, but hey, whatever works  |
alte Hexe
Posts: 4851/5458 |
THE WINNNNNNNER!
SMB3!
Since old Nick was too lazy to make this thread, I took the liberty of doing it myself! |
|
|
