(Link to AcmlmWiki) Offline: thank ||bass
Register | Login
Views: 13,040,846
Main | Memberlist | Active users | Calendar | Chat | Online users
Ranks | FAQ | ACS | Stats | Color Chart | Search | Photo album
04-18-24 01:56 PM
0 users currently in World Affairs/Debate.
Acmlm's Board - I3 Archive - World Affairs/Debate - Overthrown by OIL New poll | |
Pages: 1 2 3Add to favorites | Next older thread
User Post
Rom Manic









Since: 12-18-05
From: Detroit, WHAT?!

Last post: 6268 days
Last view: 6268 days
Posted on 02-16-07 06:07 AM Link | Quote
Originally posted by Arwon
Ethanol is a lot more efficient and cost-effective taken from sugar. America would be better off using all the money it spends to subsidise corn-derived ethanol to import biofuel from Brazil, a country which is now self-sufficient in terms of fuel thanks to its massive ethanol industry.

Brazil meets its own needs with less than 1% of its land devoted to sugar.


The point I tried to get across was that Ethanol is not a substitute, just a partner to Oil. You cannot realistically switch to ethanol. If what the advertisements say are true, then one radish can fuel a car when converted to Ethanol. So one radish to every car, lets say there's 100 million on earth running. Now, how long does it take to refuel your vehicle? Maybe once every few days?

I do not mean to remove Ethanol as a useful substance. Rather, we should be switching to hybrids that can run on both diesel (With Ethanol being it's closest relative) and gasoline.
Arwon

Bazu


 





Since: 11-18-05
From: Randwick, Sydney, NSW, Australia

Last post: 6270 days
Last view: 6269 days
Posted on 02-16-07 04:17 PM Link | Quote
Most cars in Brazil can run on anything from 100% gasoline to 100% ethanol and any mixture in between. A lot of newer cars elsewhere in the world run on any mixture as well, simply because it's easier than making separate parts for each fuel type.

I'm not sure the land-area argument holds very well, since as I say something like 0.5% of Brazillian land area is needed to run its entire ethanol industry. This is a country roughly half the size of the US popultion-wise and of a similar total area. Even if America can't get a very efficient ethanol thing going because corn syrup doesn't work very well, there's still places they grow sugar and at a pinch they can import from Brazil instead, surely? You're not going to see coast-to-coast farming purely to fuel cars.
Rom Manic









Since: 12-18-05
From: Detroit, WHAT?!

Last post: 6268 days
Last view: 6268 days
Posted on 02-18-07 01:00 AM Link | Quote
Brazil also has a large and fragile ecosystem to take care of. It's interesting, really, all that rainforest area produces so much oxygen for us to breathe...I would imagine, while that amount is significant, the amount of CO and toxins produced by burning any fuel at all may begin to damage it, if only slightly. But small damage now can be severe in the future.

While we may not see farms coast to coast, making Ethanol use widespread across the globe is not going to be effective enough to be a substitute, which is what alot of people think it will be.

But anyways, lets take a scenario: All the worlds oil is gone (We know this by the power of magic), and we need a substitute. There is no oil in the immediate vicinity of the milky way (Also known by magic). We have Ethanol, but now we have to farm our lands to great extents just to survive on fuel-oil cars.

Allow me to quote myself from another forum a long time ago (In response to a website that was pro-ethanol).

Originally posted by Blade556
According to that site, it takes one bushel of 56 pounds of grain to make 2.7 gallons (11 liters or so) of fuel. My car can fill up at about 40 liters, which is 10 gallons, which needs about 168-178 pounds of grain. Multiply that by one million people about to convert to this type of fuel and you have 168 million pounds of grain needed.

Now lets say they fill up their car every 2 days. In a month, we need 2.856 BILLION pounds of grain for every million people that need Ethanol fuel. (Note that I assumed that people filled up their 40 liter tank every month 17 times in a 30 day month)

And thats just for one million people. In a year thats 34 billion pounds of grain needed.


So thats out of the picture. The only other alternative we know of is electricity. We could use batteries to power our cars, but now we need more power to meet the electricity requirements of such a feat. So maybe we could park our cars outside during the day and use solar power to charge our batteries, and convert existing gas stations into recharge stations. But who will foot the bill of that effort? The government? But those limits aside, what does a car need to have enough torque to even move the flywheel? Can a simple battery provide enough amperage to make the car move efficiently?
Ziff
B2BB
BACKTOBASICSBITCHES


 





Since: 11-18-05
From: A room

Last post: 6268 days
Last view: 6268 days
Posted on 02-18-07 01:12 AM Link | Quote
I don't think a single law maker has claimed that it will be a substitute. Everyone sees it more as an augmentation to fuel supplies.
SamuraiX

Broom Hatter


 





Since: 11-19-05

Last post: 6269 days
Last view: 6270 days
Posted on 02-18-07 01:25 AM Link | Quote
Originally posted by Rom Manic
Brazil also has a large and fragile ecosystem to take care of. It's interesting, really, all that rainforest area produces so much oxygen for us to breathe...I would imagine, while that amount is significant, the amount of CO and toxins produced by burning any fuel at all may begin to damage it, if only slightly. But small damage now can be severe in the future.

While we may not see farms coast to coast, making Ethanol use widespread across the globe is not going to be effective enough to be a substitute, which is what alot of people think it will be.

But anyways, lets take a scenario: All the worlds oil is gone (We know this by the power of magic), and we need a substitute. There is no oil in the immediate vicinity of the milky way (Also known by magic). We have Ethanol, but now we have to farm our lands to great extents just to survive on fuel-oil cars.

Allow me to quote myself from another forum a long time ago (In response to a website that was pro-ethanol).

Originally posted by Blade556
According to that site, it takes one bushel of 56 pounds of grain to make 2.7 gallons (11 liters or so) of fuel. My car can fill up at about 40 liters, which is 10 gallons, which needs about 168-178 pounds of grain. Multiply that by one million people about to convert to this type of fuel and you have 168 million pounds of grain needed.

Now lets say they fill up their car every 2 days. In a month, we need 2.856 BILLION pounds of grain for every million people that need Ethanol fuel. (Note that I assumed that people filled up their 40 liter tank every month 17 times in a 30 day month)

And thats just for one million people. In a year thats 34 billion pounds of grain needed.


So thats out of the picture. The only other alternative we know of is electricity. We could use batteries to power our cars, but now we need more power to meet the electricity requirements of such a feat. So maybe we could park our cars outside during the day and use solar power to charge our batteries, and convert existing gas stations into recharge stations. But who will foot the bill of that effort? The government? But those limits aside, what does a car need to have enough torque to even move the flywheel? Can a simple battery provide enough amperage to make the car move efficiently?

Yes. Unless you can prove that batteries cannot produce enough energy and will never be able to, your entire contention about batteries is null and void. I beg you to explain scientifically, why it won't work. Switch grass (pretty sure it's that) can be used for biomass, along with numerous other plants. Efficiency increases with research, to a point, this you completely ignore. When the need comes up, people will be forced to invest in alternative energies. And there's always coal burning for electricity, if nothing else. Which can be improved substantially, in decreasing emissions.
Pages: 1 2 3Add to favorites | Next older thread
Acmlm's Board - I3 Archive - World Affairs/Debate - Overthrown by OIL |


ABII

Acmlmboard 1.92.999, 9/17/2006
©2000-2006 Acmlm, Emuz, Blades, Xkeeper

Page rendered in 0.025 seconds; used 376.31 kB (max 448.35 kB)