(Link to AcmlmWiki) Offline: thank ||bass
Register | Login
Views: 13,040,846
Main | Memberlist | Active users | Calendar | Chat | Online users
Ranks | FAQ | ACS | Stats | Color Chart | Search | Photo album
05-29-24 11:19 AM
0 users currently in World Affairs/Debate.
Acmlm's Board - I3 Archive - World Affairs/Debate - If there is a hell,some good people go there
  
User name:
Password:
Reply:
 
Options: - -
Quik-Attach:
Preview for more options

Max size 1.00 MB, types: png, gif, jpg, txt, zip, rar, tar, gz, 7z, ace, mp3, ogg, mid, ips, bz2, lzh, psd

UserPost
Rom Manic
Posts: 239/557
Essentially, if you don't sin, or ask for forgiveness from the bottom of your heart for sins, you will go to heaven. If you don't follow gods will, you go to hell. Simple as that.

Which doesn't mean hell is a bad place. It's just not heaven
ziratha
Posts: 87/105
That is the thought I was trying to express, albeit poorly.
Silvershield
Posts: 307/587
Originally posted by ziratha
I just have to say, isn't the thought that "good" people automatically go to heaven kinda like saying that god grades on a curve?
How so? Are you saying that, if everyone murders and steals and commits other sinful acts, then those people that commit those acts the least often are somehow good?

Good is not a relative term that is meant to refer to those people who are the "least bad."
ziratha
Posts: 86/105
I just have to say, isn't the thought that "good" people automatically go to heaven kinda like saying that god grades on a curve?
Jomb
Posts: 309/448
Well, the person who started the thread does'nt believe in hell either, so i figured it'd be cool
Rom Manic
Posts: 237/557
I think I got that one covered in my post, ziff . Unless I misunderstood what you meant...
ziffhasnoaim/password
Posts: 240/292
Originally posted by Silvershield
Does nobody here have the capacity to think in abstractions? Surely, if Heaven and Hell exist, the forms that they take are far beyond the realm of human comprehension.


I like abstracting the unknown into something that is humorously common, yet would be such a bizarre and alien circumstance
witeasprinwow
Posts: 376/613
Originally posted by Jomb
Does Lucifer rule over hell? Is there even such a place? I dont believe it for a second. That's why i was joking about it earlier.

I read somewhere, a long time ago, that the names Lucifer, Satan, etc. were names they used because they happen to be the same names as some of the deities the people were worshipping at the time outside of christianity (the pagans), and they selected those names to basically smear the name of the pagan's gods and try to convince them that their gods were evil and they needed to switch to christianity. Also as justification for persucating against these pagans (its easy to make people hate a group of people who obviously "worship the devil")

(edit- i remember now that the same source said that lucifer as depicted in the drawings of the time was intentionally made to resemble a certain Greek/Roman deity for the same reason)


Christmas was also selected to it's current day because it shared a holiday with a Roman god, to try and make Christianity more appealing and to discourage the Romans from feeding them to the lions. Didn't work very well, it seems.

But if you don't believe in hell... Then why are you in this thread? It says "if there is a hell" right at the top
C:/xkas bio.asm
Posts: 1119/1209
according to dictionnary.com:

lucifer

1: The archangel cast from heaven for leading the revolt of the angels; Satan.

2: The planet Venus in its appearance as the morning star.

3: lucifer A friction match.

4: (Judeo-Christian and Islamic religions) chief spirit of evil and adversary of God; tempter of mankind; master of Hell [syn: Satan, Old Nick, Devil, the Devil, Lucifer, Beelzebub, the Tempter, Prince of Darkness]

5: lighter consisting of a thin piece of wood or cardboard tipped with combustible chemical; ignites with friction; "he always carries matches to light his pipe" [syn: match, friction match]

6: brilliant star, a title given to the king of Babylon (Isa. 14:12) to denote his
glory.

7: Lucifer, bringing light


[Middle English, from Old English, morning star, Lucifer, from Latin Lcifer, from lcifer, light-bringer : lx, lc-, light; see leuk- in Indo-European Roots + -fer, -fer.]

look at the seventh one, this could definitely be a deity name. I also believe if Luci- was a prefix for light, since a few french word use it for stuff related to light(lucide, luciole etc.)
Jomb
Posts: 307/448
Does Lucifer rule over hell? Is there even such a place? I dont believe it for a second. That's why i was joking about it earlier.

I read somewhere, a long time ago, that the names Lucifer, Satan, etc. were names they used because they happen to be the same names as some of the deities the people were worshipping at the time outside of christianity (the pagans), and they selected those names to basically smear the name of the pagan's gods and try to convince them that their gods were evil and they needed to switch to christianity. Also as justification for persucating against these pagans (its easy to make people hate a group of people who obviously "worship the devil")

(edit- i remember now that the same source said that lucifer as depicted in the drawings of the time was intentionally made to resemble a certain Greek/Roman deity for the same reason)
drjayphd
Posts: 803/1170
Originally posted by witeasprinwow
Originally posted by MathOnNapkins
When this person dies what is the status of their soul?


We don't know. We're not supposed to know. We can guess, but we can't know.

At least according to Catholicism, we don't know the exact measurements of who goes to heaven and who goes to hell. We know that certain things are good will help you get into heaven, and that certain things are bad and will push you towards hell, but there's no formula to find this out.

And even if we did have a formula for it, I don't think that would be enough information to run it. How bad was he in the past? Was he going to honestly change for the better?


Actually, it's kinda funny you say that... doesn't it look something like this?

But yeah, unless someone comes back and can tell us what heaven or hell is like, and prove they're right, we'll never know. It's for you to decide. Kind of like if you prefer ten commandments or just one.
Silvershield
Posts: 305/587
I can't help but be utterly stunned whenever someone proposes that he will be able to somehow "make the best of" Hell, should he end up there. As if there's some sort of loophole.

Or, conversely, when a person imagines how boring Heaven must be, because it's full of stuck up, goody two shoes saints, and angels flying around playing harps. Does nobody here have the capacity to think in abstractions? Surely, if Heaven and Hell exist, the forms that they take are far beyond the realm of human comprehension.
witeasprinwow
Posts: 369/613
Originally posted by Grey
So where does the first commandment stand in all of this? I mean, it's pretty cut-and-dry: Don't believe in any deity but God. But people who don't believe in God are breaking the first commandment: "Thou shalt have no other gods", etc. Do the Ten just not apply to certain denominations?


They apply more to beliving Christians than those who don't believe, in a way. Accepting Christianity means you accept rules that come with it. Those who find another set of rules aren't necessarily breaking the rules out of maliciousness, but simply because they do not recognize Christianity.

Again, I am not defending Fundamentals who take every word literally.
Young Guru
Posts: 124/279
I've heard that commandment interpreted many different ways. One of which is that if you are aware and believe in God (meaning, not just someone telling you that there is one God, but that you understand it and really believe it) you shall not worship any other god.
There's also the idea that if you live a good life you are infact worshiping God by doing his will of loving one another.
Also, it could be viewed as don't worship unimportant things like money, material posesions, etc.

That's what I have to say about that.
Schweiz oder etwas
Posts: 1523/2046
So where does the first commandment stand in all of this? I mean, it's pretty cut-and-dry: Don't believe in any deity but God. But people who don't believe in God are breaking the first commandment: "Thou shalt have no other gods", etc. Do the Ten just not apply to certain denominations?
ziffhasnoaim/password
Posts: 234/292
That is somewhat debateable. The idea of Spheric worlds exists all over Christian and Middle-Eastern theology. The Muslim "Hell" that was written about in the Middle Ages was spheric. Those Muslims and their crazy idea of agent intellects. But that is neither here nor there.

The way I look at it...I'll see most people in Hell. You know, for a full eternity. I just hope that they die for me so that they suffer an eternity and however longer more than I.
Rom Manic
Posts: 232/557
Originally posted by ziffhasnoaim/password
You're Catholic educated, you should know about the diversity of beliefs that the Church harbours as well as the historical difference that has existed in the Church's variety of beliefs.


Who do you mean? I'm a Greek Orthodox Christian, FYI.
witeasprinwow
Posts: 363/613
Originally posted by ziffhasnoaim/password
Canon, theology, and popular belief are quite different.

You're Catholic educated, you should know about the diversity of beliefs that the Church harbours as well as the historical difference that has existed in the Church's variety of beliefs.


Acceptable answer

I was made to read Paradise Lost in high school, but never read Dante. All I know is that he's responsible for the levels or circles of Hell that you hear about.
ziffhasnoaim/password
Posts: 233/292
Canon, theology, and popular belief are quite different.

You're Catholic educated, you should know about the diversity of beliefs that the Church harbours as well as the historical difference that has existed in the Church's variety of beliefs.
Rom Manic
Posts: 230/557
I think going to heaven is another name for ascension. We all "apparently" have a soul, but yet our machines and our own eyes even cannot see it.

What logical explanation can be made from this? Someone said it exists, so somehow it must be real (Not sarcasm, it just looks like it).

MY explanation (And this is what I've told many people who get confused about heaven and hell) is that we vibrate on a certain level, as do most things in the physical world. Our molecules move just as fast as the table you're probably sitting at, or the glass of water in your tap. That is vibration.

So what if our physical bodies and souls are not much unlike the Jaffa and the Goa'Uld on Stargate SG-1? What if we are just shells protecting something much more valuable? Something that grows with us, learns with us, shares our feelings....Essentially is who we are, but something different at the same time.

So the heaven and hell thing...At most, hell and heaven are 2 different planes of existance, possibly operating on the same vibration level, but might be different levels entirely (Referring to the "Going up to heaven" and "Going down to hell" thing).

Some might think this as anti-semetic or whatever, but look at the facts. The people who witnessed the events depicted in the bible were barely able to understand the concept of a hammer, let alone cosmic vibration levels. The best way "God", whoever he may be, must have been "Going up to heaven for doing my will, or you get the banhammer all the way down to hell".

...Yeah...Thats my best explanation by scientific means...Anyone else have a guess?
This is a long thread. Click here to view it.
Acmlm's Board - I3 Archive - World Affairs/Debate - If there is a hell,some good people go there


ABII

Acmlmboard 1.92.999, 9/17/2006
©2000-2006 Acmlm, Emuz, Blades, Xkeeper

Page rendered in 0.015 seconds; used 374.98 kB (max 443.60 kB)